Sails is a section of troutswirl that is devoted to presenting questions for discussion and debate on the nature and possibilities of haiku. Sails will be overseen by Peter Yovu. For an introduction to this section, see Sails.
………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….
In interviews, writers are often asked: “Why do you write”? I don’t think I’ve ever come across the question: “Why do you read”? For us, the question is: “Why do you read haiku”? If you are a writer, do you bring a poet’s sensibility to reading, or something different? If you are that rare person who does not write but only reads haiku, please tell us what your experience is. If anyone wishes to tell the story of their first encounter with haiku, please do. What effect does it have upon you? What would you tell others to encourage them to read haiku (or perhaps you could change the question slightly and say how you like to read—while listening, for example, to Debussy, or to Led Zeppelin)? There are of course many questions within the question presented, and that will likely always be the case. And by the way, in a few weeks a new “sail” will be hoisted, but that does not mean this subject will be closed. In time, I hope, there will be an accumulation of many questions and many responses which may be visited and revisited at any time. Okay then, I look forward to what you have to say. I’ll drop a line or two myself at some point.
≈




{ 34 comments }
← Previous Comments
Next Comments →
Quick heads up. The 2nd Sailing while be posted very soon. In the meantime, if you haven’t said a few words about why you read haiku, won’t you take a moment and do so?
By the way, sometimes I like to *look* at haiku. If there was ever a haiku photographer (or some such illogic) it was Henri Cartier-Bresson. I look at (read) his haiku-photographs to experience the geometry of things. Click on my name for an example. Notice for one, the jux of cobblestones and cakes….
I hope I’m not too late. I couldn’t let the subject of bears go by without adding some haiku of Carol Purington. Carol certainly knows here bears”
Spring thaw
bear prints
on the picnic table (Carol thinks this is an unpublished haiku so I guess it’s published now)
Moon of Baby Bears
In the quiet-shadowed room
the children’s dreams
Our eyes
following the path through tall grass –
bear-bent
Chokecherry ripeness –
beyond the bear’s gorging
white-cold hunger
Carol has sent all of these haiku to me with permission to publish them here on this blog. If you’d like me to forward the e-mail with the permission I will be happy to do so.
If you want to know why I read haiku, Carol is one of the reasons. Carol is a quadraplegic. When I met her I was battling paralysis. I am now facing the fact that I may have to deal with that again as I age. I got the news today and today I got Carol’s bear haiku. She had to look them up. She has other tanka bears also.
Carol also sent along roses…ancestry, fragrance and thorns.
I read haiku for people who speak my language. I am not alone. And I am full of gratitude and wonder in the friendships haiku has brought me that help me deal with “bears.”
Others have already pointed out many of the reasons I read haiku, but I’ll throw in my two cents.
The simplest response would be that I enjoy it and reading a well-written haiku makes me unbelievably happy. When I read a haiku that blows my mind or makes me think in a new way, I’ll often have a lighter step for the rest of the day.
My needs for writing and reader haiku overlap. Depending on the day, I may be looking to strengthen my skills as a writer, and other days as a reader, but in the end, they complement one another. As a writer, I like to see what others are writing (Michael Welch made a good point about catching up with friends), and what seems to work for them–word choice, style, form. As a reader, I look to become more perspective, but also to let my mind explore new territory and come to a better understanding of the haiku, of the art of haiku, of people around me, etc.
Perhaps more importantly I find reading haiku to be a discipline in its own way. Something that must be done on a regular basis to seriously engage the art and the community. But at the same time, it’s therapeutic, and sometimes I approach reading as a meditative practice. Sometimes I will read haiku to pause and breath, to take a break and to put myself in a certain frame of mind–to let go and to open up. Haiku is a form of escape without really escaping reality. It merely means stepping back and looking at things quietly. Haiku offers an experience for both the reader and writer that is equally welcoming (albeit challenging at times) to both parties. I’m fond of the the fact that the text, the lines/words are just the beginning. Perhaps what I’m trying to say is that even as a reader I am participating. I am not just the recipient of the poem, but then providing something back by my own reading/interpretation of it.
As others have noted in their own practices, I often read for inspiration and always keep a pen and paper nearby while reading. How I read affects how I write not only my haiku, but my prose and story telling. Sometimes I think haiku is what I was looking for for years but never really realized until I found it.
Getting back to Roberta’s bear, I find that “unspoken” quality that is so vital to poetry that is condensed in haiku. It’s the mystery of the thing.
The universal unknowing that you feel priviledged to grasp which seems to be so satisfying to the human psyche.
One response I have to this 1st Sailing comes in the form of a question. If you find yourself in a room with two windows, one large, a picture window perhaps, and the other tiny, which one are you drawn to?
Peter,
Thanks for your question. I follow my thought about haiku taking us into intuition echoing Michael Dylan Welch and Bloom–poems expand consciousness. Yes. Where the intuitive reaches, for example, just happended now as I re-read Lee Gurga’s poem that ends with the milky way.
That poem took me to my step-dad’s barn, countless nights walking from the barn, to the wondering I imagined then about my future, to the now that is my lunch hour expanded. So I am imagining life over a ham sandwich because of his poem–and what Mr. Welch says about connecting to infinity. I wish it were easily articulated. Its more easily travelled in the province of haiku.
The Speculations Bob Spiess wrote now over 10 years ago used to suggest to me that the place where a haiku touched the human was at the nexus of intuition and image. This is a place that is less bound, and I believe, we return to it for the freedom we seek in poetry. It changes the mind in a way that opens. So that’s where I go over a ham sandwich. Make sense? Your thoughts? Thanks for the blog, people.
I read haiku for multiple reasons. One is because a good haiku, for me, is an approach to infinity. Somehow, it collapses time in its focus on the instant. That instant becomes eternal and makes the universe — in both time and space — feel as one. The whole universe feels like it snaps into place. Thus a good haiku is both comforting and transcendent, even if the subject matter might be dark.
Another reason is much more practical. Anyone who has been involved with the haiku community for any length of time soon makes friends, and virtual friends, with many other haiku poets writing this poetry. So reading haiku is a simple way to “catch up” with one’s friends! When I receive a haiku journal, I scan the index and turn to poems by particular people. Of course, you have no way of knowing if the poem is recent or several years old (even if just published), nor should we assume that all haiku are strictly autobiographical, but even if we are not catching up with each friend’s personal life, we can read haiku to catch up with the art of each friend’s haiku life, and that too is a valuable blessing. It’s enjoyable and stimulating to see if favourite writers are branching out to new ways of writing, or if something we know has been going on in their life has inspired a particularly strong or moving haiku that we haven’t yet read. The name of each poet is a sort of “brand” and I always enjoy seeing what various poets are doing — and in reading poets who are new to me.
Another reason to read haiku, of course, is for the variety of voices. Sometimes we write haiku in a narrow comfort zone, and it’s good to understand where those boundaries exist. Reading sufficient amounts of haiku (or any poetry) will help us better understand our poetic limitations and perhaps suggest avenues for new exploration. I’ve long thought that we shouldn’t read haiku (or other kinds of poetry) just for the sake of understanding ourselves, but also to understand others. Sure, the poet should have some degree of respect for his or her audience to make the poem reasonably clear. But sometimes the reader also needs to move — to understand where the POET is coming from. Thus the “strangeness” that exists in some haiku may be the fault of the reader just as often as the writer. In The Art of Reading Poetry, Harold Bloom says that “poetry at its greatest . . . has one broad and essential difficulty: it is the true mode for expanding consciousness.” This difficulty, he says, he has “learned to call strangeness.” As I have written elsewhere, we should apprehend haiku not just from where we are, but from where the poet is. This is why it is important to read haiku regularly. For some of us, haiku is as essential as breathing.
Indeed, as any writing teacher will tell you, the best way to learn poetry is to read as much of it as you can. The same is true of haiku — which, I believe, requires trained readers just as much as trained writers (I believe Seamus Heaney has pointed this out before). Anyone who is new to haiku should read plenty of haiku simply to learn haiku — to see what works and doesn’t work, and figure out why. Anyone who is more seasoned haiku can still continue to read haiku for these reasons. Fortunately, whatever the reasons might be for someone to read haiku, the poems themselves remain their own best reward, and I’m grateful to countless haiku writers who have enriched my life, and also my own poetry, by the examples of their haiku.
Michael Dylan Welch
My First experience with haiku came from reading a book by Jane Reichold. I have no idea why I read it. Just purchased it on Amazon. Then on line had the good fortune to meet Anya,Kirsty Karkow and others who have guided me. We belong to a community willing to help novices learn the craft. In part due to the communities openness and that of the art form itself I read it and write something most days.
I think haiku addresses a key aspect of experience and one which troubles the mind: the yes-no of ultimate meanings in experience. The gap between the parts as I understand it and try to practice it allows a flash of otherwise non-cognitive awareness to happen; I used to call that “the hinge of heaven” but “heaven” doesn’t say these days what I mean. Haiku addresses the existential problem indexed by thinkers as the ontological difference. Haiku among poetic forms is wonderfully suited to this job of work.
I read haiku to be inspired and to discover what inspires others. I read it to discover the small and large events that make up a life, and how these events in the lives of others often are similar to the events in my own life. I read it to discover how other poets capture these events so perfectly in such a short poem and hope to gain some insight into how to write my own.
← Previous Comments
Next Comments →
{ 1 trackback }